How to Fight a DUI Case in PA

How to Fight a DUI Case in PA

Any attorney fighting a DUI case in Allegheny County and the remaining counties in Western Pennsylvania must have the necessary training, experience and skill needed to take on the challenge. Never assume that you are guilty of DUI because you drank alcohol or had drugs in your system. There may be defenses available in your case that a skilled DUI lawyer can attack. This article is designed to highlight some of the possible defenses that might apply to your DUI case.

Unlawful Traffic Stop Defenses

One potential line of attack in your DUI case centers around whether or not police officers illegally pulled you over. Typically, police officers will conduct a traffic stop on individuals when they’ve observed one or more vehicle code violations. Police officers need probable cause to perform a traffic stop when you’ve committed a vehicle code violation that does not require further investigation, such as observing you drive with a broken taillight. Alternatively, they need reasonable suspicion to believe you committed a traffic violation to stop your car for traffic offenses requiring a further investigation. However, Pennsylvania case law prohibits officers from stopping vehicles for “momentary and minor” violations, such as briefly crossing the fog line with your tires.

If you were subjected to a traffic stop without the necessary reasonable suspicion or probable cause, your attorney can file a Motion to Suppress Evidence. If successful, evidence obtained against you cannot be used at trial, which may lead to a withdrawal of your charges.

Attacking an Officer’s Observations Regarding your Physical Condition

After pulling you over, police officers will pay close attention to your physical characteristics which may be indicative of impairment. Common terms of art that police will refer to include:

  • A strong, moderate or mild odor of alcohol emanating from your breath or person;

  • Slurred, slowed and deliberate speech;

  • Bloodshot and glassy eyes;

  • Disheveled or messy clothing and appearance;

  • Fumbling for your license, insurance and registration;

  • An unstable or unsteady gait upon exiting vehicle;

Police officers draw conclusions about your behavior despite only having encountered you for a matter of minutes. Medical symptoms and behavioral traits can be misinterpreted as evidence of intoxication by a police officer who knows little to nothing about your background.

No Proof that you Drove, Operated or Exercised Physical Control Over the Movement of a Vehicle

The first element in all DUI charges requires the Commonwealth to prove that you actually drove, operated or exercised physical control over the movement of a vehicle. There are cases that arise where individuals are simply “sleeping it off'“ in a parked car with the engine running and the heat/AC on. In other cases, police and other witnesses never see you drive a car at all. These cases are very fact specific, and require careful analysis by your attorney.

Insufficient Proof of Impairment

Pennsylvania has DUI General Impairment charges that apply in drug and alcohol related DUI cases. For these charges, the Commonwealth must also prove that you were incapable of safe driving, or in other words, that drugs or alcohol substantially impaired normal physical or mental faculties that are essential to safe driving. An inability to establish impairment can lead to an acquittal on the general impairment charge. In some cases, hiring a defense expert toxicologist may be necessary.

Field Sobriety Test Defenses

In Pennsylvania, there is no requirement that an individual submit to Field Sobriety testing. However, law enforcement officers will never tell you that the test is not required, so most clients end up submitting to field sobriety tests.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has created a curriculum to train officers in a standard procedure to administer three standardized field sobriety tests: the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN), Walk and Turn (WAT) and One Leg Stand (OLS). Police officers are trained to look for “clues of impairment” during the performance of these tests. If you demonstrate clues of impairment during the performance of the tests, police will typically place you under arrest for DUI.

There are many issues that arise during the Field Sobriety Test phase, which include:

  • Improper administration of Field Sobriety Tests;

  • Not providing proper instructions to the suspect;

  • Improperly documenting clues of impairment, or noting clues of impairment that are defined by NHTSA;

  • Administering tests that are not certified by NHTSA, such as having the driver recite the alphabet backwards, count backwards, or the Romberg balance test;

  • Administering tests for individuals who have medical problems that will skew test results.

Breath Test Defense - Observation Period

Chemical testing of your BAC through breath testing will occur at a police station or state police barracks. Title 67 Section 77.24 sets forth a mandatory observation period, where by a police officer or certified breath test operator must observe you for at least 20 consecutive minutes prior to administering the first alcohol breath test. The officer or breath test operator observing you must be able to establish that you didn’t drink fluids, regurgitate, vomit, eat, smoke, or chew gum. This is to ensure that that there is no mouth alcohol present to skew your testing results.

During this observation period, it is rare for a police officer or breath test operator to be watching you for 20 minutes straight. Typically, they’ll divert their attention away from you, choosing to prepare police reports or enter information into an Intoxilyzer device rather than staring at you for 20 minutes straight. This line of inquiry could potentially create doubt in the minds of jurors hearing your case.

Breath Test Defense - Mouth Alcohol Contaminating Sample

Although prosecutors will often claim that slope detectors will prevent mouth alcohol from contaminating breath test results, these devices aren’t foolproof. Clients with Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GERD) may experience a faulty test result due to reflux of ethanol from the stomach, which will contaminate the breath test result. If slope detectors are successful at keeping mouth alcohol from contaminating results, then why does the government require a 20 minute waiting period? Additionally, asthma medications may skew test results.

Breath Test Defense - Improper Calibration or Device Malfunctioning

Breath testing equipment must be subject to regular maintenance, testing and calibration. Breath test operators are required to obtain two consecutive breath tests from the suspect, and then also administer simulator tests used simulator solution designed to give a reading of .10% after the conclusion of your 2nd breath test. If your breath test results, or the simulator results, differ from an allowable amount, the breath testing equipment must be placed out of service, calling into question the validity of your test. However, many officers overcome equipment problems by simply taking the suspect to a hospital for blood alcohol testing.

Challenging Warrantless Blood Test

In the 2016 case of Birchfield v. North Dakota, the United States Supreme Court ruled that in order for police to pursue a blood test of a DUI suspect, they must either have a warrant, or an exception to the warrant requirement must be present. Based upon this decision, Section 3803 of the vehicle code was modified to enhance the grading of DUI offenses where the driver refused blood test when there was either a warrant, court order, or other constitutionally permissible basis.

Consent to a blood draw is an exception to the warrant requirement. Police officers continue to request chemical testing without warrants, claiming that a warrant is not necessary because the suspect consented to blood testing. Determining whether or not police obtained valid consent to chemical testing requires a careful consideration of the individual case facts.

Blood Test Defenses

When blood samples are drawn from a DUI suspect, they must be collected, stored and analyzed correctly. The testing equipment must be properly calibrated and in good working condition. To pose a challenge to the validity of blood results, your attorney cannot rely upon the standard “discovery packet” provided by the District Attorney’s Office. Your lawyer will need to file special discovery requests to necessary info from the lab, including equipment maintenance records, calibration records, and records documenting the qualifications of lab scientists. You will need to hire an expert laboratory data auditor to review the laboratory documents to ensure that the laboratory is following proper testing protocols. This type of defense can be very costly.

Violating the Two Hour Rule

In Alcohol DUI cases, the Commonwealth must prove that your BAC was a .08% or greater within two hours of the time you drove, operated or exercised control over the movement of a vehicle. The failure to obtain the blood or breath sample within two hours of the time you were seen driving may lead to a dismissal of your case.

However, Section 3802(g) provides an exception, allowing for the admissibility of BAC evidence obtained more than two hours after driving where the Commonwealth shows good cause explaining why the chemical test sample could not be obtained within two hours, and establishes the suspect didn’t drink alcohol or use drugs between the time of arrest and the time the sample was taken.

An unnecessary delay of over two hours between the time of your traffic stop and the time of testing may prohibit the Commonwealth from offering your BAC into evidence, which may substantially hamper their prosecution.

Trust the Zuckerman Law Firm for your DUI Defense

Mounting a proper defense to a DUI case can be costly when experts such as toxicologists and lab experts are needed. Before making a decision on whether or not to fight your DUI case, it is important for your attorney to discuss the facts with you along with pricing and options.

Whether you choose to fight your DUI or pursue a plea agreement, you need the right advocate in your corner. Attorney Dave Zuckerman has litigated evidence suppression motions, non-jury trials and jury trials on DUI cases. He has prosecuted or defended hundreds of DUI cases in his career. If you’re charged with a DUI and believe there’s a defense to your allegations, contact the experienced DUI defense team of the Zuckerman Law Firm at 412-447-5580.

Person Not to Possess Charges Dismissed for Man Facing 10-20 years in Prison

Attorney Nicholis Milardo represented a client charged with two counts of Persons Not to Possess Firearms, two counts of Carrying a Firearm Without a License, Tampering with Physical Evidence and providing False Identification to Law Enforcement. Due to the client’s past criminal record, he was facing a standard range sentence of 10-20 years of incarceration if convicted on the firearms offenses. Due to confidentiality concerns, names and case details will be omitted from the description.

The client was accused of being a back-seat passenger in a vehicle, to which two firearms were found in the vicinity of the vehicle’s driver. The client was accused of constructive possession of the firearms even though he did not drive or own the vehicle containing the weapons, and there was no DNA or fingerprint evidence to connect the weapons to the client. The defense had a strong argument to present to the jury that there was insufficient evidence to prove that the client had the power and intent to control weapons found in the vehicle.

Due to unreasonable plea offers, the firm prepared for a jury trial. During the course of his preparations, Attorney Milardo discovered statements which helped to exonerate his client. Upon bringing these statements to the attention of the prosecutor on his case, a plea offer was negotiated for the client to plead guilty to providing a False Identification to Law Enforcement, a 3rd-Degree Misdemeanor, for time served. All felony firearms charges were withdrawn.

In cases where multiple individuals are found in a vehicle containing drugs or guns, police will typically proceed to charge everyone with the crimes under a theory of joint constructive possession. With careful preparation, Attorney Milardo helped ensure that his client would not be imprisoned for decades for a crime he didn’t commit.

Attorney Nicholas Milardo Selected to National Trial Lawyers Top 40 Under 40 List

We are please to announce that in January of 2020, Attorney Nicholis Milardo was selected by the National Trial Lawyers as a Top 40 Under 40 Attorney for Criminal Defense in Pennsylvania. The NTL Top 40 Under 40 is a professional organization composed of the top trial lawyers from each state or region who are under the age of 40, and membership is by invitation only.

According to the NTL website: “Membership is extended solely to the select few of the most qualified attorneys from each state who demonstrate superior qualifications of leadership, reputation, influence, stature and public profile measured by objective and uniformly applied standards in compliance with state bar and national Rule 4-7. Invitees must exemplify superior qualifications, trial results, and leadership as a young lawyer under the age of 40. Selection is based on a thorough multi-phase objective process which includes peer nominations combined with third-party research.”

Joint Criminal Defense Representation: Can a criminal defense attorney represent two co-defendants in Pennsylvania?

CAN ONE CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY REPRESENT TWO PEOPLE CHARGED WITH THE SAME CRIMES?

If you have found our website, you are likely searching for an answer on whether or not a criminal defense attorney can represent two co-defendants in a criminal case. Or in other words, can two individuals who are accused of committing the same crimes or are involved in the same incident be represented by one lawyer? The Zuckerman Law Firm LLC has represented individuals charged in connection with the same incident in Western Pennsylvania, and this decision has been made with careful consideration of the facts and issues.

Is there a conflict of interest associated with joint representation? Can this conflict of interest be waived?

The simple answer is that in most cases, a conflict of interest will exist. A conflict of interest may arise when an attorney represents two parties who are charged as co-defendants (both accused of committing the same crime) or cross-complainants (two individuals accusing one another of crimes, typically in domestic assault cases).

The Rules of Professional Conduct state generally that an attorney should not represent a client if by representing one client, the other client would be negatively impacted. A clearcut example is a scenario where Client A and Client B are in a vehicle where drugs are found, where Client A blames Client B for the drugs, and Client B blames Client A for the drugs. In this scenario, it is impossible to represent one client without harming the other client’s interests.

However, some conflicts of interests can be waived under the Rules of Professional Conduct if the lawyer believes he can provide competent and diligent representation to each client, representation is legal, representation doesn’t involve asserting a claim by one client against another client, and each client gives informed consent.

Examples where joint representation was provided by the Zuckerman Law Firm

Our firm has jointly represented clients charged in connection with the same incident. Generally speaking, our firm has done so for preliminary hearings and traffic cases when clients are not accusing one another of wrongdoing, the clients have similar defenses or arguments to be presented in court, or other circumstances make it likely that the case will not proceed to a full hearing or trial in the future. Here are some real-life case examples where our firm accepted joint representation:

  • Case 1: Husband and wife charged with Simple Assault on one another, where both parties are refusing to testify under the 5th Amendment, and there is no independent evidence to prove the charges against one another without their testimony. Charges were dismissed for insufficient evidence against both parties.

  • Case 2: Boyfriend and girlfriend were accused of assaulting a third party. Both parties asserted that Client 1 had no role in the altercation, and Client 2 acted solely in self-defense. The firm represented both parties at a preliminary hearing, and the parties obtained separate legal counsel for trial. Both parties were found not guilty at trial.

  • Case 3: Boyfriend was charged with a DUI and girlfriend was charged with marijuana possession. Girlfriend told police the marijuana was hers, and the boyfriend was not charged with it. As a result, the clients were not blaming one another for the narcotics, so joint representation was appropriate. Girlfriend’s charges were withdrawn by agreement, and boyfriend entered ARD on DUI charges.

  • Case 4: Boyfriend and girlfriend charged with possession of drugs and paraphernalia found within the home. Both parties made admissions that the items found therein belonged to the both of them. As a result, the parties were not blaming one another. One case pending, other case resolved with plea to summary disorderly conduct.

  • Case 5: Father and son accused of stealing equipment they believed was abandoned. Both parties acknowledged taking the items, unaware that they belonged to someone else. As a result, both parties had consistent defenses, making joint representation possible. Both parties received ARD for the case.

  • Case 5: Husband and wife were accused of a Racing on Highways traffic offense. Both parties had discussed the matter fully before contacting the firm, denied having been involved in a racing incident, and were asserting the same defenses. The firm jointly represented the couple, obtaining not guilty verdicts for the racing offenses.

Here are some real-life examples where our firm rejected joint representation:

  • Case 1: Person A was accused of attempting to activate stolen cell phones at a retail location, and Person B was waiting behind in a vehicle. Given the likelihood that Person B would blame everything on Person A, joint representation was rejected.

  • Case 2: Boyfriend and girlfriend were charged with assaulting one another. A third-party witnessed the acts committed by each individual. Cross examination of this third-party witness could have benefitted one client and hurt the other. As a result, joint representation was rejected.

The decision on whether or not to accept joint representation is made after a careful consideration of the facts, defenses and related issues.

What are the benefits and downsides to joint representation?

Typically, a reduction in cost is the biggest benefit, as co-defendants may typically pay less to have one lawyer attend a hearing rather than hiring separate lawyers. Furthermore, in cases where co-defendants are not blaming one another and are seeking similar outcomes, joint representation may be appropriate.

However, there are significant downsides to joint representation. With standard representation, information provided by one client to an attorney is kept confidential. With joint representation, information provided by one client may be shared with the other client, and vice versa, which may be detrimental. Furthermore, with cases that proceed past the preliminary hearing phase of prosecution, attorneys will typically not represent two parties at trial, leading one party to have to change lawyers midway through the case.

I’d like to seek a consultation for joint representation. What should I do?

First, our office recommends that only one individual contact the Zuckerman Law Firm LLC at 412-447-5580 for a free consultation. This individual should be sure to contact the firm in a private setting where nobody can overhear the conversation, including the other party involved.

There is a reason we do not recommend a joint consultation amongst co-defendants. First, the attorney-client privilege protects communications made between an individual and his attorney only. If another party is privy to the conversation, the statements made during the consultation may not be privileged, and may be used against you in court.

Second, the attorney needs to properly determine whether there is a conflict of interest, and whether or not it can be waived. If the attorney determines that the conflict cannot be waived, it is important that they have only heard one party’s version of events. If the attorney cannot waive the conflict, and has heard both parties speak on the matter, it might prohibit the attorney from representing anyone on the case. As a result, it’s recommended that the lawyer speak with one party first and then make a decision on whether or not to proceed with individual or joint representation.

If you and a friend or loved one are seeking joint criminal defense representation, please contact the Zuckerman Law Firm at 412-447-5580. If joint representation makes sense, we can have the parties sign paperwork to proceed forward. In cases where joint representation would be unethical, our firm can refer one party to another qualified criminal defense attorney to ensure that everyone involved receives the proper representation they deserve. Our firm strives to make the right ethical decision in each scenario.

Reckless Driving and Following Too Closely charges amended to avoid license suspension

The firm is please to announce that a negotiated agreement was reached whereby Reckless Driving and Following Too Closely charges were amended to two counts of Traffic Control Devices, eliminating a 6-month mandatory license suspension and 3 points from the client’s driving record.

The client stood accused of getting into a rear-end collision while traveling through the Fort Pitt Tunnels in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. The accident was not witnessed by any member of law enforcement, but was filed after the drivers called police to report the accident. Unfortunately, when auto accidents occur, local police officers and state troopers often feel compelled to issue traffic citations to the at-fault driver that may lead to points or a license suspension.

If convicted of Reckless Driving, the client faced a mandatory 6-month driver’s license suspension. To make matters worse, as the client was required to drive for a living, the suspension would have effectively caused the client to lose her job. Additionally, the Following Too Closely offense would carry 3 points on a driving record upon conviction.

Upon researching these consequences, the client and her family chose to trust the Zuckerman Law Firm for representation on this matter. Familiar with Pennsylvania case law on Reckless Driving prosecutions, the firm was prepared to proceed to a hearing if required. However, on the hearing date, Attorney Nick Milardo was able to negotiate an agreement to amend the charges to traffic control device violations under Section 3111A. This resolution carried no license suspension or points, and will have no impact upon the client’s employment.

In Reckless Driving cases, we prepare for trial while working behind the scenes to pursue a desired outcome. Both the client and firm were very satisfied with the outcome.

Not guilty verdict on Simple Assault charge in Allegheny Co. Non-Jury Trial

The Zuckerman Law Firm is pleased to announce that our client was found not guilty of Simple Assault after a non-jury trial in Allegheny County. To protect the confidentiality of the parties involved, names and certain case details will be excluded.

Through testimony, public records and exhibits, the following was presented: In the summer of 2019, the victim and his wife were going through a divorce. The wife had begun dating the firm’s client, and the client had taken his new girlfriend and her children for an evening out. Prior to leaving, the victim and his wife had exchanged messages about their plans for the evening, where the wife made it clear that she was going to be taking her kids with her to see the client. In response, the victim made it clear that he did not want his children around the client, and told his wife he would arrive at their location despite not being invited. Approximately 2-3 hours later, the victim arrived at their location, hid behind bushes, and relayed his observations to a friend on the phone.

About 20 minutes later, the victim and client had a verbal argument, whereby the victim claimed that he was sucker-punched in the back of the head. However, the client told police officers that the victim repeatedly threatened him, and had threatened to cause harm to his own estranged wife. Furthermore, the victim threatened to “end him” and made a reaching motion towards his pocket, leading our client to believe he was grabbing a gun. The client rapidly grabbed the victim’s head in self-defense, releasing his head when discovering that he did not have a gun in his hand. The defense argued that at the time the client grabbed the victim’s head, the client had a reasonable belief that he was in danger of bodily harm.

Evidence presented at trial undermined the credibility of the victim. First, the victim told police that he had just left work, went to visit his wife and kids, and did not know the the client would be present. These claims were clearly contradicted by text messages and the victim’s own prior testimony. Second, testimony revealed that the wife had been physically abused in the past by the victim, and that she communicated this information to the client. Being aware of these violent tendencies, the client believed that the victim was going to harm him at the time he acted in self-defense. Third, although the victim claimed he did not want a confrontation, his actions that day demonstrated otherwise, since: (1) he verbally threatened the client (2) he threatened to give evidence to the client’s wife to use in their divorce and (3) he lowered a shoulder into the client’s chest/torso area when entering a bus stop. Fourth, there were pending divorce claims in family court, establishing a potential motive for the victim to testify adversely against the client, and in a manner that minimized his involvement in the incident.

Given the lack of serious injury and the client’s lack of a criminal record, this should have been a case that resolved at the magistrate level or through the ARD diversionary program. However, the victim took a completely unreasonable stance about the matter, as he was seeking revenge against the man who his wife dated. As a result, the case went to trial.

After hearing the evidence, the Court rendered a not guilty verdict as to the count of Simple Assault, and found the client guilty of a summary offense for harassment, imposing fines and a 90-day non-reporting probationary period. The client will become eligible to expunge the Simple Assault charge from his criminal record.

This case demonstrates how a single witness with dubious credibility can impact how a case proceeds through the system. Thankfully, through careful preparation, the firm was able to tell the other side of the story, leading to the correct outcome.

Not Guilty Verdict in Simple Assault Trial Involving Firearms

The firm is pleased to announce that after a 2.5 day jury trial in October of 2019, the firm’s client was found not guilty of Simple Assault, Recklessly Endangering Another Person and Terroristic Threats.

In 2018, the firm’s client was confronted and threatened by a female who exited her vehicle and lifted her shirt, displaying a firearm on her waistband. In response, the client pulled his firearm out of his pocket and told the female to not touch her weapon. In speaking with police, the female denied having a weapon. The investigation conducted by law enforcement was highly troubling, as they failed to search the female’s vehicle, her purse, or the other occupant in the vehicle. Additionally, they listed the other vehicle occupant as a crime victim without even taking a statement from that individual.

Attorney Zuckerman conducted an investigation which was key in presenting the truth to the jury. Despite the victim’s denial that she had a gun in her possession, it was determined that she was a high-ranking member of a radical political organization that promotes gun ownership amongst its female members. During cross examination at trial, it was further revealed that the female had a valid license to carry firearms, something both the police and District Attorney’s office failed to investigate or disclose to the defense. The client also testified in his own defense and several character witnesses were called to testify about his reputation for being a peaceful, law abiding citizen.

Ultimately, the trial judge granted a Motion for Judgment of Acquittal as to the Recklessly Endangering Another Person charge, finding that there was insufficient evidence to submit the charge to the jury. For the other counts, the jury deliberated for approximately 25 minutes before rendering a not guilty verdict. It is rare that jury deliberations take less than an hour, but to this jury, it was clear that the client was innocent.

This case is a clear example of the dangers that occur when members of law enforcement fail to thoroughly investigate conflicting accounts of an incident before filing charges. This case also highlights the benefits of having an experienced Pittsburgh criminal defense attorney to investigate and defend against bogus accusations.

Contraband and Drug Possession Case Withdrawn in Indiana County

A ZLF client was charged with two separate cases in Indiana County, Pennsylvania. The first case was for Drug Possession. The second case was for Contraband and Drug Possession. Essentially, the client was arrested for the first case and notified members of law enforcement that narcotics were located in a pant pocket. Thereafter, the client was transported to the jail where additional narcotics were found in the same pant pocket. As a result of the second search that occurred in the jail, the client was charged with Contraband, a 2nd Degree Felony, and Drug Possession, a 1st-Degree Misdemeanor. Both offenses carried a maximum sentence of up to 13 years in jail.

At the preliminary hearing, the firm was successfully able to convince the District Attorney’s office that the client should have never been charged with Contraband in the first place, as there was no evidence to establish that drugs were being smuggled into the county jail. Specifically, had law enforcement thoroughly searched the client during the initial arrest, no drugs would have been found at the county jail. As a result, all charges at the second case were withdrawn, allowing the client to avoid a felony conviction without the time and expense of trial.

Armstrong Co. Client avoids 5-10 years of jail time on Prescription Fraud Case

The Zuckerman Law Firm represented a client facing 18 total counts for Insurance Fraud, Acquisition of a Controlled Substance by Misrepresentation, Forgery and Theft by Deception in Armstrong County. The information listed in this article is a matter of public record, and does not include the disclosure of confidential information.

The client stood accused of writing fake prescription medications over a span of several years. Specifically, full confessions were made by the Defendant to the employer and members of law enforcement. Due to the high number of Schedule II controlled substances acquired, the client’s Offense Gravity Score was increased to a 13, carrying a range of guideline sentences from 5-10 years, up to 6.5-13 years.

Pursuant to lengthy negotiations that occurred between the firm and Attorney General’s Office, an agreement was reached where the prosecution agreed to reduce the Offense Gravity Score from a 13 down to a 5 in return for a guilty plea to Acquisition of a Controlled Substance by Misrepresentation and Insurance Fraud. The agreement was accepted, but sentencing was left to the discretion of the Court. The guideline range sentence for the reduced OGS still carried anywhere from probation to 9-18 months in the county jail.

Prior to sentencing, the firm prepared and filed a detailed memorandum explaining the client’s rehabilitative efforts in a request for probation. At sentencing, the Court agreed that the client deserved a probationary sentence, and imposed a 2 year period of probation. This case serves as an important example as to why humanizing your client with both prosecutors and the court can be an effective tool in achieving justice.

Armstrong County Clients Found Not Guilty of Racing on Highways

Our firm is pleased to announce that our clients were found not guilty of Racing on Highways offenses in Armstrong County, Pennsylvania. This verdict saved both clients from incurring a mandatory 6-month driver’s license suspension.

A husband and wife couple stood accused of Racing on Highways after being lined up in adjacent lanes along a local highway. Upon the traffic light turning green, the citing officer claimed to have heard tires squealing and saw both vehicles accelerate to a point approximately 1/10th of a mile down the road, before one vehicle slowed and the other continued. The officer then proceeded to stop both vehicle charging the couple with Racing on Highways. One driver was also charged with exceeding speed limits in excess of 31mph, which carries a mandatory 15-day license suspension.

At the summary trial, the testimony of both clients was presented, establishing that neither party was engaged in a drag race as required by the statute. The court ultimately found the clients not guilty of this offense. However, the court found one driver guilty of speeding below 31mph, eliminating the 15-day suspension, and the other guilty of an inspection violation, carrying a fine only.

Charges Withdrawn Against Allegheny Co. Man Falsely Accused of Stalking, Harassment & Theft

Our firm is pleased to announce the decision made by prosecutors to fully withdraw felony Theft and misdemeanor Stalking and Harassment against a client who was falsely accused of domestic violence. The client faced a total of 6 separate legal actions as a result of unfounded allegations: 2 criminal cases, 1 PFA, and 3 ICC complaints. This blog post is being made with the client’s direct consent.

Upon learning that our client was in a relationship with another woman, his ex-girlfriend filed for a PFA, and accused him of stealing his own vehicle, which was titled in his ex’s name to lower insurance costs.

After posting bond on the theft case, his ex-girlfriend subsequently accused him of sending threatening text messages to her on three separate occasions. Police ultimately filed three separate indirect criminal contempt complaints (ICC) against the client without ever securing the alleged text messages as evidence, forcing him to pay thousands of dollars to bail bondsmen to secure his release. Police thereafter charged him with Stalking and Harassment.

Social media evidence sent by the ex-girlfriend to the client ultimately cleared his name. At the conclusion of the preliminary hearing on the theft charges, the ex-girlfriend sent a message to the client using her social media account, threatening to ruin his life if he would not take her back.

Thankfully, the client followed our advice for handling domestic violence allegations by preserving a copy of the message and providing it to legal counsel. This message in conjunction with other exculpatory text messages were reviewed with prosecuting attorneys, who made the responsible decision to withdraw all of his criminal charges. Additionally, all PFAs and ICC violations were withdrawn in family court.

Although victorious in a court of law, this came at a great cost to the client, who spent thousands of dollars in bond money and attorney’s fees to clear his name.

Increased Penalties for DUI and Suspended License Violations Likely Under Senate Bill 961

In April of 2018, the PA State Senate voted 45-4 to approve Senate Bill 961, which would change the PA Motor Vehicle Code under Title 75 to increase penalties for DUI offenders, and those who drive on suspended licenses. Although this bill is still awaiting approval in the House, it is strongly anticipated that it will pass and be signed into law.  This article is designed to highlight some of the differences in penalties between current Pennsylvania law and the law if SB 961 is approved.

Driving on a DUI Suspended or Revoked License

The biggest impact of this law will be on the treatment of those who drive on suspended licenses. Currently, a person who drives on a DUI suspended license who is not a habitual offender faces a summary offense punishable with a mandatory minimum sentence of 60 days of incarceration and a $500 fine, regardless of the number of prior convictions.

Since the DUI Suspended License cases are filed as summary offenses, typically District Attorneys offices are not involved in proceedings until the Summary Appeals phase, which allows significant latitude to negotiate pleas before the Magisterial District Courts. That will soon change, as the following modifications would apply: 

  • Second Conviction for 75 Pa.C.S. 1543(b): Grading remains a summary offense carrying a mandatory 90 day jail sentence and a $1000 fine. This change increases the mandatory minimum sentence by 30 days and adds $500 to the total fine.  
  • Third or Subsequent Conviction for 75 Pa.C.S. 1543(b): Increases the grading to a 3rd Degree Misdemeanor with a mandatory minimum jail sentence of 6 months in jail and a mandatory $2,500 fine. This modification turns the violation into a criminal matter, increases the mandatory minimum sentence by 4 months, and the mandatory fine by $2,000. 

DUI Penalties

The current DUI Penalties can be found here. Under current Pennsylvania Law, the highest graded offense that an offender will face is a 1st Degree Misdemeanor punishable by a maximum sentence of 5 years. Under SB 961, an offender will be charged with a 3rd Degree Felony punishable by a maximum sentence of 7 years if: 

  • It is the offender's 4th DUI Offense; 
  • It is the offender's 3rd DUI Offense if charged with a Highest Tier DUI for Drugs, having a BAC exceeding a .16%, refusing a breath test, or refusing a blood draw if requested pursuant to a warrant, court order, or other constitutional basis; or
  • The offender has a prior Homicide by Vehicle While DUI conviction. 

It does not appear that SB 961 impacts the mandatory minimum jail sentences applicable to 3rd and 4th offenses, but merely modifies the grading from an M1 to an F3. 

Homicide by Vehicle while DUI and Non-DUI

Current law treats a Homicide by Vehicle While DUI offense as a 2nd Degree Felony with a mandatory minimum prison sentence of 3 years. Under SB 961, for those with one prior DUI (includes convictions, acceptance of ARD, acceptance of a consent decree, or juvenile adjudication), the grading of the offense will be enhanced to a 1st Degree Felony with a mandatory minimum prison sentence of 5 years. If the offender had two or more prior DUI offenses (includes convictions, acceptance of ARD, acceptance of a consent decree, or juvenile adjudication), the offender faces a mandatory minimum sentence of 7 years. 

For a Homicide By Vehicle offense not involving DUI, the court may, but is not required to, sentence an offender who is convicted of HBV and a Driving Without a License under Section 1501 or Driving on a Suspended License under Section 1543 to an additional 5 years of incarceration. The bill also calls for sentencing guideline enhancements when a person operated their vehicle without a license. 

Aggravated Assault by Vehicle While DUI and non-DUI

Whether it's an Aggravated Assault by Vehicle While DUI under Section 3735.1 or an Aggravated Assault by Vehicle under Section 3732.1, the court may, but is not required to, sentence an offender who is also convicted of Driving Without a License under Section 1501 or Driving on a Suspended License under Section 1543 to an additional 2 years of incarceration. The bill also calls for sentencing guideline enhancements when a person operated their vehicle without a license. 

Accident Involving Death or Injury While Not Properly Licensed

Under current law, Section 3742.1 of the Vehicle Code only punishes an individual who is not properly licensed and causes an accident resulting in injury or death to another. If the accident causes serious bodily injury or death, the offense is graded as a 3rd Degree Felony. All other injuries qualify for a 2nd Degree Misdemeanor grading. 

However, SB 961 would modify the law to punish unlicensed drivers who both cause accidents, and those who are involved in accidents through no fault of their own. If a driver who is unlicensed is involved in an accident, and the driver didn't cause the accident, the driver will now be charged with a 3rd Degree Misdemeanor if anyone else involved suffered serious bodily injury, or a 2nd Degree Misdemeanor if anyone died as a result of the accident. Put simply - an unlucky unlicensed driver who is involved in an accident through no fault of their own will now face criminal charges if someone was injured. 

Summary

The media focus on this law deals with the addition of felony DUI charges and enhanced mandatory penalties for Homicide by Vehicle offenders. However, the most significantly impacted segment of society will be those whose licenses are suspended because they cannot afford to pay DUI court costs. These individuals will continue to see their fines and penalties increase substantially if this bill is signed into law. 

 

Refuse a Warrantless Blood Draw? Highest Tier DUI Penalties May Not Apply

DUI Refusal penalties are some of the harshest penalties under Pennsylvania law. A DUI Refusal charge is a shorthand term for a DUI General Impairment with Refusal offense. In these cases, the Commonwealth must prove that the accused drove, operated or exercised physical control over the movement of a vehicle after imbibing a sufficient amount of alcohol to render the accused incapable of safe driving. To seek the increased DUI penalties for refusing a chemical test, the Commonwealth must also prove that the defendant refused to provide the requested blood or breath sample. 

In addition to the mandatory 12 or 18 month civil license suspensions, Sections 3803 and 3804 of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Code treat DUI Refusals as Highest Tier offenses, the same as if your BAC exceeded a .16%. While a first offense DUI General Impairment offense carries no mandatory jail time, a first offense DUI Refusal carries a 72 hour mandatory minimum jail sentence. A second offense DUI General Impairment is an ungraded misdemeanor which carries a 5 day mandatory minimum and a 6 month maximum sentence. However, a 2nd DUI Refusal increases the grading of the offense from an ungraded misdemeanor to a 1st degree misdemeanor, which carries a 90 day mandatory minimum jail sentence and a maximum sentence of 5 years. 

In the 2016 Birchfield vs. North Dakota decision, the United States Supreme Court held that warrantless blood draws occurring in the absence of exigent circumstances are unconstitutional. After Birchfield, the Pennsylvania Superior Court held that the DUI Refusal penalties and enhanced gradings do not apply to offenders asked to submit to warrantless blood draws where police lack exigent circumstances to request a warrantless blood draw. 

In Commonwealth vs. Mario Giron (155 A.3d 635), police initiated a traffic stop after observing the defendant side swipe a parked vehicle. Upon approaching the vehicle, the officer noted a strong odor of alcohol coming from the vehicle, and that the defendant had red, glassy eyes and slurred speech. Upon exiting the vehicle, the defendant had unsteady footing, and was placed under arrest for DUI. He was asked to submit to a blood draw, and not a breath test, and was read a 2008 version of the DL-26 form, which provides chemical test warnings to the driver. The defendant refused to read or sign the form, and subsequently refused to perform the chemical test. The defendant was found guilty of the M1 DUI General Impairment with Refusal, and was given a 90 day to 5 year jail sentence. 

The Superior Court ultimately upheld the DUI General Impairment conviction, but overturned the DUI Refusal enhancements. Specifically, the Court held that under Birchfield, in the absence of a warrant or exigent circumstances justifying a search, a defendant who refuses to provide a blood sample when requested by police is not subject to the enhanced penalties provided in 75 Pa.C.S.A. §§ 3803-3804. The case was sent back to the trial court so that the defendant could be re-sentenced on the DUI General Impairment (5 day mandatory and 6 month maximum) and not the DUI General Impairment with Refusal (90 day mandatory and 5 year maximum). 

Please note that this ruling is limited to cases where (1) a blood draw was the only form of requested testing (2) the blood draw request was done without a warrant and (3) the blood draw request was done without there being exigent circumstances present. If you refuse a breath test, you will still be subject to the DUI Refusal penalties. This decision also has no impact on the civil license suspensions imposed as a result of refusing chemical testing. 

As always, any person facing a DUI charge should not attempt to defend themselves regardless of any legal research they've conducted over the internet. If you're charged with a DUI in Pennsylvania, contact an attorney immediately. 

Penn State University student avoids Public Drunkenness and Disorderly Conduct Convictions

Recently, the Zuckerman Law Firm represented a college student at Penn State University, who was cited with public drunkenness and disorderly conduct. The client was accused of being intoxicated at an apartment complex, leading security to contact police, who in turn issued citations. If convicted, the client faced up to $900 in fines and court costs, along with publicly searchable convictions. 

Represented by Attorney Zuckerman, the court granted counsel's request to dismiss charges when the police officer failed to appear in court as required. Based upon the favorable resolution, the client is now able to pursue a criminal record expungement, to remove the case information off of the PA Unified Judicial System Portal. 

If you are a Penn State Student cited with an offense in Western Pennsylvania, please feel free to contact the Zuckerman Law Firm at 412-447-5580 for a free case consultation.